In the fast-paced world of merchant cash advance (MCA) funding, where businesses snag quick capital based on future sales, funders face a lurking threat: usury claims. Picture this: you’ve advanced $50,000 to a merchant, expecting a percentage of their receivables in return, only to find yourself in a New York courtroom defending against accusations that your agreement is an illegal loan charging excessive interest.
This scenario isn’t hypothetical—it’s the reality unfolding in courts across the country. For MCA funders, understanding usury and crafting ironclad contracts isn’t just smart—it’s survival. Let’s dive into why usury matters, how it threatens your investment, and how a merchant cash advance attorney can help your business with savvy contract drafting.
Usury is the illegal practice of charging excessive interest on a loan, and in New York, it’s not just a civil slap on the wrist—it’s a crime. Under New York Penal Law § 190.40, anyone who “knowingly charges, takes or receives” interest exceeding 25% per annum commits criminal usury in the second degree, a class E felony. For MCA funders, the stakes are high: if a court deems your agreement a loan rather than a purchase of future receivables, you could lose your advance, face penalties, or worse. Merchants often wield usury as a defense when they default, claiming the MCA’s terms are predatory. But here’s the good news: courts frequently uphold MCAs as legitimate purchases—if they’re structured right.
So, how do courts decide if your MCA is a loan subject to usury laws or a bona fide purchase? The three-factor test New York courts use:
In Samson MCA LLC v. Joseph A. Russo M.D. P.C. (2023), the Fourth Department tossed a usury defense because the MCA checked these boxes. Principis Capital, LLC v. I Do, Inc. (2022) followed suit. The lesson? Nail these factors, and courts are likely to dismiss usury claims.
Here’s how to bulletproof your MCA agreements:
Compliance with New York law is non-negotiable—disclose terms upfront and avoid interest-like fees that could tip the scales toward usury.
A rock-solid MCA contract doesn’t just dodge usury—it wins in court. Work with an MCA attorney who knows New York’s ropes, and you’ll recover with force, not flounder in legal quicksand. In this game, good drafting isn’t optional—it’s your lifeline.
Don’t wait for a usury claim to disrupt your funding operations. At David I. Mizrahi Law P.C., we help MCA funders structure agreements that stand up in court and aggressively defend against legal challenges.
Contact us today to safeguard your business and ensure your contracts are enforceable under New York law.
Usury refers to charging interest above the legal limit, which in New York is 25% annually. If an MCA is viewed as a loan rather than a purchase of receivables, it could trigger a usury claim.
Yes, if an MCA lacks proper structuring, like no reconciliation clause or a fixed repayment term, it may be reclassified as a loan. This reclassification can expose funders to usury allegations.
Include key elements like reconciliation provisions, an indefinite term, and limited recourse in the contract. These demonstrate that the MCA is a purchase, not a loan.
They may try to void the agreement and avoid repayment. However, courts often uphold MCA contracts if they follow the proper legal structure.
It allows payments to adjust based on the merchant's revenue, showing that repayment isn’t fixed. This supports the argument that the transaction is a receivables purchase, not a loan.
Providing a New York judgment attorney with the judgment, debtor information, payment history, asset details, prior collection records, and underlying contracts can create a clearer foundation for evaluating judgment recovery options.
A New York restraining notice can help judgment creditors prevent certain transfers of a debtor's property or funds while pursuing lawful judgment recovery and other post-judgment enforcement remedies.
.jpg)
A perfected UCC-1 can help secured creditors pursue a merchant’s bank accounts and receivables after default through targeted enforcement and collection efforts.
A UCC lien only protects you if it's enforced — here's how our MCA collections attorney turns a filed lien into actual recovered funds before a defaulting merchant can move assets out of reach.
Before deploying your first dollar as a new MCA funder, here's the contract package purchase agreement, guaranty, UCC-1, and default provisions our merchant cash advance lawyers say you can't afford to skip.
Renegotiating an MCA deal after a merchant default can strengthen your recovery odds or quietly undercut your enforcement rights, here's how our MCA lawyers structure amendments to keep your agreement airtight.
This guide outlines seven essential evaluation questions to help MCA funders choose a dedicated debt recovery lawyer who can enforce contracts, defeat borrower defenses, and seize assets through court-backed recovery tools.
This article outlines the five judicial enforcement tools including UCC lien execution, pre-judgment asset freezes, subpoenas, direct litigation, and bank levies that give an MCA collections attorney far greater recovery power than a standard collection agency.
What happens when MCA co-funders can't agree on litigation, settlement, or timing after a merchant default and how a New York MCA lawyer helps resolve it.
As merchant cash advance defaults climb, more funders are bringing in a merchant cash advance attorney earlier in the collections process to protect recovery rates before assets and receivables are claimed by competing creditors.
Enforcing a judgment in New York involves a defined sequence of legal steps, from properly filing and docketing the judgment to locating assets and ultimately securing payout, and understanding each stage helps judgment creditors avoid unnecessary delays
Judgment enforcement timelines vary widely depending on factors like debtor assets, jurisdiction, and the collection method used, making it essential to understand what drives delays before pursuing collection.
A merchant cash advance is legally a purchase of future receivables, not a loan — and that distinction can hide serious risks a merchant cash advance attorney should catch before you sign.
What Happens When a Business Can't Keep Up With MCA Payments And How a Merchant Cash Advance Attorney Can Help
Repeated late payments are an early warning sign of a bigger cash flow problem — the earlier you track the pattern, tighten your terms, and escalate to a collections debt attorney if needed, the more leverage you keep and the better your chances of getting paid without a formal collection case.
An effective business collection demand requires precise debt calculations, concrete contract evidence, and firm legal deadlines to create immediate leverage and compel defaulting debtors to pay before litigation begins.
This article explains why judgment enforcement for debt often fail and what creditors can do to improve their chances of recovery.
This article explains which assets creditors may pursue after a New York judgment is entered and why legal strategy matters in post-judgment collection.
This section explains the first items a debt collections attorney needs, including contracts, invoices, timelines, demand letters, payment records, and written communications.
This article explains the first documents a debt collections attorney needs, including contracts, invoices, payment history, demand letters, and communications, to build a stronger collections for debt recovery strategy.
This funder-focused article explains how bankruptcy can affect MCA obligations, including the automatic stay, claim treatment, and strategic reasons to negotiate outside court.
A merchant cash advance attorney reviews processor agreements to catch hidden collection rights, set-off clauses, and ACH risks before they trigger surprise withdrawals.
Actionable guidance for funders on steps to take when a debtor claims no assets, focusing on reexamination, renewal, asset tracing, and measured enforcement.
Aggressive judgment enforcement can improve recovery rates, but creditors and funders must remain compliant with applicable laws, debtor protections, privacy requirements, and ethical standards.
MCA collections attorneys help funders resolve UCC priority disputes by protecting creditor rights and enforcing secured recovery interests.
Judgment attorneys help creditors recover unpaid commercial debt by enforcing court judgments and pursuing strategic asset recovery solutions.
MCA funders use attorneys to enforce UCC liens, protect secured interests, and improve recovery outcomes in commercial financing disputes.
Judgment attorneys use asset investigations and legal enforcement tools to help creditors locate hidden assets and recover unpaid debts after court rulings.
Hiring the right collections attorney in New York can help businesses recover outstanding debt efficiently while protecting their legal and financial interests.
An MCA attorney can help businesses secure and manage merchant cash advance funding more effectively by providing legal guidance and contract oversight.